Today, we’re going to explore one of the most intriguing storytelling techniques: the unreliable narrator. And what better way to do so than by examining a masterpiece of in deception—The Usual Suspects. By the end of this video, you’ll not only understand how to craft an unreliable narrator, but you’ll also be ready to weave a narrative so compelling, it might just be a smash hit.
1. Establish Credibility with the Audience
One of the key reasons the unreliable narrator in The Usual Suspects works so well is because of how the film establishes Verbal Kint’s credibility early on. The audience sees him as a harmless, physically weak con-man—someone who seems incapable of orchestrating the elaborate crimes described. His seemingly honest, unassuming demeanour lowers our incredulity, making us more susceptible to his lies.
For example, when Verbal relates the events of the heist and the mysterious figure of Keyser Söze, it is with a sense of awe and apprehension that seems genuine. He’s not trying to convince the police or the audience of his insight; rather, he presents himself as a survivor of a terrifying experience. This makes him relatable and trustworthy, a vital component for an unreliable narrator. Without this initial credibility, the final twist wouldn’t have nearly the same impact.
2. Use Misdirection
An unreliable narrator thrives on misdirection, guiding the audience to focus on details that seem important, but ultimately obscure the truth. The Usual Suspects succeeds because it peppers the narrative with red herrings, creating a complex web of lies that only fully unravels at the end.
Consider how Verbal introduces the idea of Keyser Söze. The story of this somewhat mythical figure is filled with enough detail to make it seem real. Yet, those details are so outrageous and dramatic that they divert suspicion away from the possibility that Verbal himself could be Söze. The audience is so busy trying to piece together the puzzle of Söze’s identity that it overlooks the inconsistencies in Verbal’s story. This misdirection is the key to keeping the audience engaged and off-balance.
“Deception in stories lies at the heart of crafting an unreliable narrator.”
3. Use the Narrator’s Perspective to Shape Reality
An unreliable narrator doesn’t simply tell a story; he or she shapes the reality within the story. This is where The Usual Suspects shines—Verbal’s narration controls what the audience sees and understands, crafting a version of reality that aligns with his deception.
Throughout the film, the scenes we witness are directly tied to Verbal’s narration. We see what he describes, but these scenes are not objective truths; they are coloured by his perspective. For example, the detailed flashbacks to the heist and the events leading up to it are presented as facts, yet these are merely fabrications designed to construct a believable narrative. The film’s cinematography supports this, blending Verbal’s words with visual cues that make his lies feel real. The audience is drawn into this constructed reality, which is essential if the final twist is to pack a punch.
4. The Power of Consistent Inconsistencies
A convincing unreliable narrator can get away with telling outrageous lies if those lies are consistent within the story’s framework. Verbal’s story contains inconsistencies, but they are subtle enough to be overlooked or explained away by the complexity of the tale.
Verbal makes seemingly insignificant mistakes like misremembering details or offering somewhat conflicting accounts of the same event. These inconsistencies are blamed on the stress or the trauma of the events he’s recounting. For instance, the coffee cup moment where Agent Kujan suddenly realises that many of the details in Verbal’s story were lifted from objects in the room is indeed a revelation. But because those inconsistencies are minor and seem unimportant, they are dismissed by Kujan and the audience. This technique keeps us hooked while also planting the seeds for the eventual twist.
5. The Climactic Revelation
The most crucial aspect of an unreliable narrator is properly managing the final revelation—the moment when the truth is unveiled, and the audience realises it has been deceived. This revelation needs to be shocking yet believable in hindsight, a feat The Usual Suspects pulls off flawlessly.
The climax, when Verbal Kint walks out of the police station, his limp disappearing, and the pieces of his deception falling into place, is a stroke of genius. The montage of the items in the office that Verbal used to fabricate his story—Kobayashi’s name, the details of the story, unfolds in quick succession, leaving both Agent Kujan and the audience stunned. This revelation is powerful because it is earned. It is the culmination of every lie, every misdirection, and every deception that came before it. We are left feeling off-balance, not just because we have been deceived, but because how brilliantly this has been done.
Summary
To write a brilliant unreliable narrator, establish his or her credibility from the start, master misdirection, use perspective to shape reality, maintain consistent inconsistencies, and deliver a climactic revelation that ties it all together.