How Moral is your Story?

Aristotle's statueAt the core of most memorable stories lies a theme with a strong ethical or moral premise.

In a very real sense, a story is about proving the theme by tracking the conflict that ensues between the hero and his nemesis, both of whom represent opposing values. In simple terms, good guys finish first, or last, depending on the outcome of that conflict.

But does this then mean that some stories are not ethical or moral? Is the nemesis’ winning of the fight, proof that unethical and immoral behaviour can triumph?

Biblical tales, for example, are clearly moral – Noah, Cleopatra, The Ten Commandments. As are modern stories, such as Braveheart, The Firm, Gladiator, Oblivion, Edge of Tomorrow, and countless others. These tales have at their core a moral premise that states that if the hero does the right thing, he will eventually achieve the goal, carry the day, save the world, even if it sometimes means that he has to sacrifice himself to do it.

But what about less obvious examples? Seven? Fight Club? Inception? Oceans 11,12,13? in what sense do these stories espouse ethical or moral values?

This bothered me quite a bit because, deep down, I felt that all great stories promote the best in us rather than the worst. Yet, something rang true about these latter stories. I felt a resonance and verisimilitude in them that I normally associated with great tales.

Then, during one of my classes on story-telling, it struck me: Most stories are indeed moral and ethical, with one proviso: In some, the moral or ethical judgment falls outside the world of the story itself — it is made by an audience or reader based on received cultural, social, and religious values.

Stories in which the villain gets away with it, spreading death and mayhem in his wake, may appear to show that malice, slyness, and cold-blooded determination lead to victory, but few of us would applaud his actions.

A horror story, in which, let’s say, demons succeed in taking over the world, is not necessarily a celebration of evil overcoming good. Rather, it is a warning: If the hero fails to stop evil, this is the result – a horrific world overrun by demons.

The characters within such a story may even celebrate this fact, but audiences, as a whole, won’t, since they bring their own moral and ethical systems to bare upon the tale.

Paradoxically, then, good will always rise above evil even when it seems defeated.

Summary

Most stories invoke an ethical and moral foundation, even those that ostensibly seem not to.

Invitation

If you enjoyed this post, kindly share it with others. If you have a suggestion for a future one, please leave a comment and let’s get chatting. You may subscribe to this blog by clicking on the “subscribe” or “profile” link on the bottom right-hand side of this article. I post new material every Monday.

Image: Tilemahos Efthimiadis
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/legalcode

2 thoughts on “How Moral is your Story?

  1. Stavros Halvatzis Post author

    Very pertinent comments, Anthony. It’s as if the author(s), intentionally or unintentionally, show(s) us that even if wrongdoing or evil defeats good, on the ground, the results are hollow, or worse — which in itself points us away from wrongdoing, or evil.

    Reply
  2. Anthony Mitchell

    I think most often, we want the hero to win, but a story where the hero does not can really resonate and help us understand that even when the villain wins, what does he win? He most likely had little love or positivity in his life and his life will end just like the hero’s does or did. I point to No Country For Old Men where Llewellyn Moss is killed by the cartel and Anton Chigurh lives. Yet, does he really look like a winner at the end- just out of a random car wreck that seemed to be traveling for years to get him as he says with the coin to the old man at the gas station and bleeding with a bone sticking out of his arm? Each story is different and if they all went the same, they would not be so interesting to us. I think something can be learned from most. There is such a thing as a hollow victory as well. Great post!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *